Monday, November 4, 2024

Amendment anxieties

Presented by Uber: POLITICO's must-read briefing informing the daily conversation among knowledgeable New Yorkers
Nov 04, 2024 View in browser
 
POLITICO Newsletter Header

By Nick Reisman, Emily Ngo and Jeff Coltin

Presented by 

Uber

With Timmy Facciola

Jay Jacobs speaks to reporters.

“When we win this proposal, I think everybody owes her a debt of gratitude," New York Democratic Committee Chair Jay Jacobs said about Gov. Kathy Hochul. | Mary Altaffer | AP Photo

NEW YORK MINUTE: Welcome to Election Eve. Some House Republican leaders are in New York today to stump for colleagues in districts crucial to the majority. Majority Leader Steve Scalise (R-La.) will be on Long Island for Rep. Anthony D’Esposito, and Majority Whip Tom Emmer (R-Minn.) will be in the Hudson Valley for Rep. Mike Lawler and Alison Esposito.

Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, meanwhile, will keep making the rounds for Democrats in his home state, including Rep. Pat Ryan today in the Hudson Valley. — Emily Ngo

ALL THINGS EQUAL: New York Democratic Committee Chair Jay Jacobs expects the so-called Equal Rights Amendment will pass Tuesday, but not by a robust margin.

Jacobs told Playbook a confluence of problems with the amendment, which was intended to cement abortion rights in the state constitution, hobbled it from the beginning.

Those issues include broad language on the ballot, as well as a pro-ERA campaign that spent heavily on consultants and little on voter outreach. (The group has since spent $5.1 million to persuade people to vote yes.)

That will translate to a comparatively modest result in a state where voters have generally supported reproductive rights, Jacobs predicted.

“I don’t think it will be reflective of the support that abortion rights have in the state of New York because, unfortunately, due to the way it was written, voters simply can’t understand it and Republicans can try to misconstrue it,” he said Sunday.

A year ago, the ballot proposal was considered a potential boon to Democrats — especially in pivotal House races — and a way of augmenting turnout among voters who support abortion rights.

But opponents of the amendment, which include the state GOP, Catholic bishops and a wealthy beer heir , have leveraged its expansive language to warn that approval would lead to trans people participating in women’s sports and non-citizens voting.

The language — which includes protections for LGBTQ+ people and for “national origin” — has provided an opening for attacks from the right, allowing critics to paint the measure as going beyond simply bolstering abortion rights.

Opponents want to capitalize on voter anxiety over trans people and, in a well-funded TV ad, linked the measure to the migrant crisis and its impact on New Yorkers.

“Whether it’s housing, employment, quality of life, medical care, education costs, the criminal justice system; the list goes on and on,” said Rob Ryan, a spokesperson for the group Vote No on Prop 1, which is airing the ad with the help of donor Richard Uihlein, an heir to Schlitz Brewing and GOP donor. “If passed, Prop 1 will create special rights for illegal migrants and higher state and local taxes for New Yorkers."

While supporters have rebutted these claims, some Democrats fear the efforts to get the amendment over the finish line haven’t been enough.

“I’m definitely still worried that whatever is happening now is too little, too late, and we’ve left the door open for the opponents to define the issue,” said a Democratic political operative who’s working in a battleground House race and was granted anonymity to speak frankly.

Privately, consultants on both sides of the amendment fight agree that a close margin for the amendment would be an embarrassment for Democrats, who have made abortion rights a central issue in recent campaigns.

Dysfunction over the push for the amendment led Gov. Kathy Hochul in September to redirect $1 million from the state Democratic Committee toward the effort to get the proposal approved. The committee has also sent mailers and text messages urging voters to vote yes. Hochul has appeared at multiple rallies for the amendment, including on Sunday.

Spending from the state party to boost the amendment has since doubled to $2 million as well, and Jacobs said he is personally spending $50,000 to boost the measure.

Jacobs, a Hochul ally, believes the governor should get credit for stepping in after initially taking a hands-off approach for much of the summer.

“She’s pulling it out of the fire, frankly,” he said. “When we win this proposal, I think everybody owes her a debt of gratitude.”

Jacobs believes critics of Hochul’s approach need to “get out a big mirror.” But supporters have pressed the state party to do more.

“There Jay Jacobs goes again blaming everyone except himself,” Democratic consultant Camille Rivera told Playbook. “On the day before Election Day, he should be doing everything possible to pass Prop 1 and not slinging mud. If we lose, it’s the Democratic establishment that should be to blame.” — Nick Reisman

HAPPY MONDAY: There’s one day until Election Day. Got news? Send it our way: Jeff Coltin, Emily Ngo and Nick Reisman.

 

A message from Uber:

New York City Uber riders pay $700 Million in taxes and fees annually* That’s more than the entire budget for New York City Parks Department. *Based on trips originating from NYC in 2023. Learn more.

 

WHERE’S KATHY? In New York City with no public schedule.

WHERE’S ERIC? Delivering remarks at the Department of Small Business Services’ 16th Annual Procurement Fair, and later holding a signing ceremony for a hotel licensing bill.

QUOTE OF THE DAY: “I agree with John @mulaney… let’s not call it Epstein’s Island.” — (the real) Assemblymember Harvey Epstein after an SNL skit poked fun at his name.

ABOVE THE FOLD

House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Speaker Mike Johnson attend the National Prayer Breakfast.

“Extreme MAGA Republicans want to take a blowtorch to the Affordable Care Act, but when we elect John Avlon to the House, Democrats will take a blowtorch to Project 2025," House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said, alluding to Speaker Mike Johnson’s recent comments. | Francis Chung/POLITICO

CHIPS ARE DOWN: New York Democrats seeking every edge in tight House races have pounced on Speaker Mike Johnson’s recent remarks appearing to advocate for the repeal of the Affordable Care Act and the CHIPS Act.

Johnson (R-La.) has said his “no Obamacare” response in Pennsylvania was taken out of context and has walked back his statement that the GOP “will probably” repeal the CHIPS Act — made as he stood alongside Rep. Brandon Williams in central New York, where chipmaker Micron will benefit from the law.

Williams told reporters he was lobbying Johnson on the importance of the CHIPS Act, and Johnson said in a statement afterward that he misheard the question. But there’s little time for cleanup as early voting wraps up.

“The extreme MAGA Republican majority in the House doesn’t understand central New York,” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) told reporters Saturday morning as he stumped in Syracuse for Williams’ challenger, John Mannion. “The CHIPS and Science Act is critically important to the ongoing economic revival here in central New York.”

On Saturday night, as Jeffries rallied in Suffolk County, he added that “Extreme MAGA Republicans want to take a blowtorch to the Affordable Care Act, but when we elect John Avlon to the House, Democrats will take a blowtorch to Project 2025.”

Democrat Avlon faces Rep. Nick LaLota on Long Island.

After Johnson had laid out a “very aggressive first 100 days agenda” last week in Pennsylvania, a person in the crowd interjected, “No Obamacare?”

The speaker responded, “No Obamacare. The ACA is so deeply ingrained, we need massive reform to make this work, and we’ve got a lot of ideas on how to do that.”

As he did with his CHIPS remark, he followed up with a statement, “Despite the dishonest characterizations from the Harris campaign, the audio and transcript make clear that I offered no such promise to end Obamacare.” — Emily Ngo

KEEPING UP WITH THE DELEGATION

Gov. Kathy Hochul appears at a news conference.

Long Island Rep. Nick LaLota sent a fundraising email with the subject line, “Deplorable, Garbage and now Anti-American” in reference to Gov. Kathy Hochul's recent comments. | Don Pollard/Office of Gov. Kathy Hochul

HEAPING ON HOCHUL: Hochul’s remarks disparaging Trump voters as “anti-American” were the subject of many Republican attacks this weekend as the parties seek 11th-hour advantages.

The governor condemned comments by a pro-Trump comedian calling Puerto Rico “garbage” and otherwise insulting Latinos at the former president’s Madison Square Garden rally — rhetoric that appeared to cause fallout in Pennsylvania, Nevada and elsewhere — but she may have sparked a controversy of her own.

“If you’re voting for these Republicans in New York, you’re voting for someone who supports Donald Trump, and you’re anti-woman, you’re anti-abortion, and basically you’re anti-American because you have just trashed American values,” she told MSNBC on Saturday.

Republican Conference chair Elise Stefanik responded in a statement that “the Democrat Party led by Kamala Harris is an absolute disgrace as they smear American patriots who want to save our country by supporting President Trump and Republicans.”

Long Island Rep. Nick LaLota sent a fundraising email with the subject line, “Deplorable, Garbage and now Anti-American.”

Hudson Valley Rep. Mike Lawler told the New York Post that “Governor Hochul has once again disgraced herself and the state of New York by calling supporters of some of the most bipartisan members of Congress ‘anti-American.’”

Trump and Republicans, of course, have called Democrats names aplenty, too. In August, a LoHud column brought to light a video of Lawler at a Trump fundraiser describing Democrats as “a party that hates this country.” — Emily Ngo

BETTER WITH BIDEN?: While it’s universally understood that Biden dropping his bid for reelection allowed down-ballot Dems to breathe a sigh of relief, Rep. Brandon Williams told Playbook that isn’t the case in NY-22.

Biden bowing out hurt Syracuse-area Dems, Williams said, noting that the president’s first wife is from Auburn and he attended Syracuse Law School.

“It actually helps me that Kamala’s at the top of the ticket,” said Williams, the country’s most vulnerable House incumbent. “It’s the perception that she’s a West Coast liberal, and that’s very different from New York State. Joe Biden’s got strong connections here.”

The argument may not be fully borne out in the numbers, though. Harris’ ascent coincided with a surge in campaign donations to Democrat John Mannion, Williams’ rival, in July. And while a Siena College poll from May showed 44 percent of upstate New York voters backing Trump versus 42 percent for Biden, an October Siena poll revealed 47 percent of upstaters said they’d vote for Harris while 45 percent said they’d go for Trump.

A Mannion campaign spokesperson added that supporter enthusiasm also spiked when Harris took up the mantle. — Emily Ngo

More from the Congress:

Democrats encourage voters to change registration to their second homes in the Hamptons while the Republicans urge early voting. (Bloomberg)

It’s cost $146 million so far to try to win a handful of New York House races that could help tip the balance of power in Washington. (Gothamist)

After campaign donations from John Catsimatidis, Lawler and Rep. Anthony D’Esposito used public funds to buy advertising from his radio station. (City & State)

NEW FROM PLANET ALBANY

The state Capitol in Albany, New York, is pictured.

The threats to the Department of Environmental Conservation came after several days of online outrage over the death of P’Nut, a squirrel owned by Chemung County man Mark Longo. | AP

NOT PEANUTS: Hundreds of threatening and harassing messages were sent to the Department of Environmental Conservation over the weekend following the euthanasia of a social media-famous squirrel, a state official said Sunday evening.

The State Police, meanwhile, are investigating an emailed bomb threat that targeted a DEC office in Steuben County, the law enforcement agency announced.

The threats to the DEC came after several days of online outrage over the death of P’Nut, a squirrel owned by Chemung County man Mark Longo.

The squirrel was taken by the DEC last week and later euthanized in order to test for rabies after the animal reportedly bit one of the people involved in the seizure.

The DEC did not return messages seeking comment, and Longo did not return a message sent to an email address associated with his animal sanctuary.

P’Nut’s death became a cause célèbre for the political right in the last three days — a story that combines the relatively new phenomenon of social media anger with rage for perceived government overreach.

Former Rep. Lee Zeldin tweeted a photo from the movie “Braveheart” to “win this one for P’Nut!”

Republican Rep. Marc Molinaro, who is in a tight race for a Hudson Valley House seat, tried to lump his Democratic opponent Josh Riley into the blame for P’Nut’s death. Riley doesn’t work for the DEC and is seeking office at the federal level, which does not oversee the state-level agency.

And X owner Elon Musk took up the cause of P’Nut.

“It is NOT ok for the government to barge into your home and kill your pets!” he posted. “What has become of the Land of the Free?” — Nick Reisman

JAMES IN DEMAND: Attorney General Tish James has emerged as one of the most sought-after surrogates for New York Democrats.

James on Sunday appeared in four Long Island House districts on behalf of Democratic candidates.

Later today, she is scheduled to appear in Kingston with Rep. Pat Ryan and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries. Separately, she will attend a campaign event with Democratic state Senate hopeful Yvette Valdes-Smith, who is running to unseat Republican Sen. Rob Rolison.

All these appearances dovetail with her trips to swing states on behalf of Harris’ White House bid.

James’ activity in New York races coincides with speculation over her own political future. She’s been discussed as a potential candidate for governor or New York City mayor.

James has insisted, however, that she wants to remain attorney general. — Nick Reisman

More from Albany:

Democrats hold supermajorities in the state Legislature, but Republicans are trying to claw back ground in Albany. (New York Times)

Federal and state authorities are investigating whether migrant workers hired by New York used fraudulent documents to gain employment. ( Times Union)

 

A message from Uber:

Advertisement Image

 
CITY HALL: THE LATEST

Eric Adams arrives to the U.S. federal court house.

Mayor Eric Adams said he ended his relationship with the Turkish Cultural Center in Sheepshead Bay after the political movement it’s aligned with was accused of organizing a bloody coup against Turkey’s ruling government. | Kena Betancur/AP

ADAMS IN COURT: The mayor’s trial is set to start April 21, POLITICO reports, just two months before the scheduled mayoral primary.

Friday’s hearing on Adams’ motion to dismiss the one bribery count previewed some of the arguments that could come up in the trial, including the importance of Adams’ decision to stop associating with a certain Turkish community group in Brooklyn.

As Playbook has reported, Adams said he ended his relationship with the Turkish Cultural Center in Sheepshead Bay after the political movement it’s aligned with was accused of organizing a bloody coup against Turkey’s ruling government.

But federal prosecutors said in court that Adams cut the group off at the request of the Turkish government, which is proof he understood his relationship to be “transactional” from the beginning, soon after he started getting flight upgrades from Turkish Airlines.

Prosecutors declined to provide any update on whether there could be a superseding indictment in Adams’ case. — Jeff Coltin

HE’S RUNNING: Zohran Mamdani joked he was “outpacing every other mayoral candidate in this race” in a mid-marathon interview with Playbook, conducted without breaking stride.

The crowd was responding “incredibly well” to his “Eric Adams raised my rent” t-shirt the Queens Assemblymember said at mile 14 in Long Island City — before flipping around to show the back: “Zohran will freeze it!” Mamdani has said he would hold rent-stabilized leases steady if he wins.

Caught post-race, City Council member Chi Ossé was glad to have finished his first marathon but said “I’m never running again” — singling out the Queensboro Bridge as a particular pain point.

Meanwhile, First Deputy Mayor Maria Torres-Springer underlined her title by beating her fellow deputies Fabien Levy and Anne Williams-Isom across the finish line — even after the latter was energized with half a banana from THE CITY’s Katie Honan. — Jeff Coltin

More from the city:

Thank God for Torres-Springer is the vibe at City Hall, with a sense of calm and determination settling over the scandal-scarred administration. ( City & State)

Former First Deputy Mayor Sheena Wright has resigned from her position as one of Adams’ appointees to the board of the New York City Housing Authority. (THE CITY)

Trump’s mass deportations and tariffs would have devastating consequences on the city’s fortunes, economists and scholars say. (THE CITY)

NEW YORK STATE OF MIND

A train service in Rockaway will not be available for five months next year. (Gothamist)

Parts of New York are under a drought watch. (Spectrum News)

State education officials are set to lay out what could be a major change to high school graduation requirements. (Newsday)

 

A message from Uber:

Ever thought about what it’s like to drive for Uber in New York?

Uber Drivers earn $32 per hour.* And that’s before incentives and tips

They also get benefits including dental insurance, vision coverage, mental health support, and workers’ compensation through the Black Car Fund and Driver Benefits Fund.

*Average earnings per online hour from January - July 2024 based on trips originating from NYC

Learn more.

 
SOCIAL DATA

Edited by Daniel Lippman

MAKING MOVES: Katie Jennings is joining the Citizens Budget Commission as vice president for strategy and communications. She was previously a business and policy reporter for more than a decade with Forbes and POLITICO and got her start as a freelancer for POLITICO New York’s predecessor, Capital New York.

WELCOME TO THE WORLD: Sabrina Siddiqui, national politics reporter at The Wall Street Journal, and Ali Jafri, a contractor at the State Department, on Oct. 26 welcomed Ayaan Hasan Jafri, who joins big sister Sofia. Pic Another pic

HAPPY BIRTHDAY: NYC Council member Lynn Schulman … Semafor’s Ben Smith … Assemblymember Ed Ra … Health + Hospital’s John Doyle … WaPo’s Catherine Rampell … AP’s Alex Sanz Lucretia Regina-Potter … Treasury’s Addar Levi … OMB’s Julie SiegelAvi Berkowitz Amanda Thayer Florencia Iriondo Michael Fontneau (WAS SUNDAY): State Sen. Zellnor Myrie … state Sen. Michelle HincheyAnna Wintour … CAA’s Rachel Adler Jenn PellegrinoJulian Gewirtz Scott Galloway ... Christie Stephenson Rowan Morris ... Michelle Hinchey David CaseMatthew KirincicKam Mumtaz Caroline Michelman

… (WAS SATURDAY): Assemblymember Alex Bores … NYBC’s Megan WylieLarry FinkJonathan Stahler of the U.S. Mission to the U.N. … Jen Dlouhy … Fox News’ Cam Cawthorne Kevin Cirilli … Semafor’s Jay SolomonDaniela Pierre-Bravo … NYT’s Adam Kushner and Celeste LavinAaron Weinberg of Rep. Jerry Nadler’s (D-N.Y.) office … Jamie Gangel ... Joan F. Cohen ... David Sirota ... Rebecca Rose Hastings Woolston (WAS FRIDAY): Pinchus Hikind

Missed Friday’s New York Playbook PM? We forgive you. Read it here.

 

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family

Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook

View all our political and policy newsletters

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://login.politico.com/?redirect=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to edwardlorilla1986.paxforex@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Unsubscribe | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

No comments:

Post a Comment

Could CVS Health (CVS) Be a Safe Haven as Healthcare Costs Rise?

Healthcare costs in the U.S. are surging, placing significant financial pressure on consumers, insurers, and providers. The growing demand...