Monday, July 11, 2022

How Russia and Iran’s illicit oil travels the high seas

A newsletter from POLITICO that unpacks essential global news, trends, and decisions.
Jul 11, 2022 View in browser
 
POLITICO Global Insider

By America Hernandez

Follow your guest host America on Twitter. And Ryan, too.

Happening Today

RWANDAN GENOCIDE TRIAL DRAWS TO A CLOSE: Criminal defense lawyers in Paris will today present their closing arguments for why 78-year-old Laurent Bucyibaruta, former police chief of the southern Rwandan province Gikongoro, should not be found guilty of genocide, complicity in genocide and complicity in crimes against humanity over the 1994 killing of some 800,000 minority Tutsis and moderate Hutus over 100 days.

Bucyibaruta is the highest-ranking official to be tried abroad — outside the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda — and denies the charges. On Friday prosecutors acknowledged "this man did not kill anyone," but nonetheless requested a sentence of life imprisonment, with a verdict expected Tuesday.

SRI LANKA IN TURMOIL AMID LEADERS' RESIGNATIONS: Hordes of protestors who broke into the palace of Sri Lanka's president Gotabaya Rajapaksa — and set Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe's residence on fire — have refused to leave until the leaders formally resign, which is expected to happen Wednesday.

The tired, angry and hungry swam in the garden pool, sat down to tea and spread out on beds in the palatial digs of President Rajapaksa, whose family, for the past two decades, has ruled the country — straight into the ground, many allege.

Last week the debt-logged South Asian island nation announced it was negotiating with the International Monetary Fund as a bankrupt state, as an economic crisis caused shortages of fuel, food, medicine and cooking gas, while oil reserves ran dry.

Good Monday morning, and welcome to a special energy-focused edition of Global Insider. I'm America Hernandez, POLITICO's energy policy correspondent based in Europe, filling in for Ryan Heath as he takes a much-deserved rest in the south of France.

NORD STREAM OFFLINE: The Russia-to-Germany natural gas pipeline known as Nord Stream will be out of service through at least July 21 for scheduled annual maintenance.

German Vice Chancellor Robert Habeck has repeatedly fretted that Russia's Gazprom wouldn't turn the pipeline back on after the planned outage, but would instead feign ongoing repair problems. On Sunday, French Economy and Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire said that countries " should prepare for a total cutoff of Russian gas; today that is the most likely option."

Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov has promised a "boosting of volumes" through Nord Stream once maintenance is over … should Canada return a turbine out for repair in Montreal needed to help push gas through the line.

Canadian Natural Resources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson on Saturday confirmed it would make a sanctions exception to allow the part to be reinstalled — with his ministry confirming to POLITICO's reporter in Ottawa, Zi-Ann Lum, that six turbines will soon be eastbound out for delivery. German Chancellor Olaf Scholz cheered the decision by "our Canadian friends and allies," while Ukraine's Minister of Foreign Affairs Dmytro Kuleba and Energy Minister German Galushchenko decried it as a "dangerous precedent" that "will strengthen Moscow's sense of impunity."

BIDEN'S MIDDLE EAST PLANS: In a bid to avoid Sri Lankan-style unrest and fuel shortages back home, U.S. President Joe Biden jets to the Middle East this week to beg oil-rich rulers in the region to pump more black gold and ease global energy prices.

Brent crude, the global benchmark, has been above $100 a barrel since Russian President Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine. Western leaders have blacklisted Russian oil in a bid to starve Kremlin coffers and negotiate an end to the invasion — but are now feeling the financial consequences of sidelining the world's third-largest producer and top oil exporter. Summer is peak oil season, and buyers are now chasing even fewer barrels. As politicians hunt high and low for spare fuel to keep business afloat and consumer bills down, there's a temptation to strike deals with unsavory petrostate leaders.

Biden will later this week sit down with Saudi Arabian Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman less than five years after MBS consolidated power by locking up political rivals and businessmen in a Ritz hotel and forcing them to sign over their fortunes, in what was widely termed the "Sheikh-down." Then there's the pesky assassination and dismemberment of dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi. But "Mister Bone-Saw," as MBS was subsequently nicknamed, isn't the only hardline regional leader Washington wants to turn from pariah to potential partner in the name of energy security.

Despite last month's failed indirect talks in Doha between U.S. Special Representative Rob Malley and Iran's top nuclear negotiator Ali Bagheri Kani, Biden told the Washington Post he is still hoping to revive the Iran nuclear deal — which could free up Tehran's crude stocks for global consumption.

Former Iranian Deputy Interior Minister Mostafa Tajzadeh blamed the Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on Twitter for stalling the deal so far — and was promptly thrown in jail Friday for "spreading lies to disturb public opinion." Iranian film director Mohammad Rasoulof and his colleague Mostafa Aleahmad were also rounded up Friday on separate dissident charges.

ABE'S LEGACY: In the wake of Shinzo Abe's shocking assassination on Friday, his party's ruling coalition swept elections, returning a supermajority in the upper house that shores up Prime Minister Fumio Kishida's to base. Secretary of State Antony Blinken took a side trip to Tokyo to pay respects for the fallen leader; a funeral will be held Tuesday.

 

INTRODUCING DIGITAL FUTURE DAILY - OUR TECHNOLOGY NEWSLETTER, RE-IMAGINED:  Technology is always evolving, and our new tech-obsessed newsletter is too! Digital Future Daily unlocks the most important stories determining the future of technology, from Washington to Silicon Valley and innovation power centers around the world. Readers get an in-depth look at how the next wave of tech will reshape civic and political life, including activism, fundraising, lobbying and legislating. Go inside the minds of the biggest tech players, policymakers and regulators to learn how their decisions affect our lives. Don't miss out, subscribe today.

 
 
GLOBAL RISKS AND TRENDS

BLAST KILLS SEVEN CHILDREN IN TOGO: Sunday explosions in northern Togo killed seven children and wounded two . Last month, Togo declared a state of emergency in the region, citing threats of Islamist attacks from the northern border with Burkina Faso, where a jihadist insurgency is threatening to spill over into coastal West Africa. The Togolese military refrained from immediately describing the incident as an attack, saying "an investigation is ongoing to determine the circumstances of this explosion and identify the perpetrators."

NO GAS FOR KARACHI: Despite weeks of scorching heat and prolonged blackouts, Pakistan has received no offers on its $1 billion tender for additional liquefied natural gas deliveries from July through September. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif turned to Afghanistan for help, which began shipping coal over by rail at a reported 30 percent markup. Chinese energy firms operating in Pakistan have balked at the hike, and are now threatening to stop those Afghan coal imports unless prices come down.

Ed Cox , head of global LNG at commodity intelligence firm ICIS, said Pakistan's failure to secure extra gas on global markets is "obviously a direct consequence of Europeans' rising LNG demand" as EU buyers snap up all available cargoes in a bid to pivot away from Russian supply. "The European payment premium of just over $14 per [million British thermal units of gas] to East Asia is exceptional, we've never seen this before," Cox told Global Insider. "Qatar is the main supplier to Pakistan, Bangladesh and India through long-term contracts at prices much lower than the spot price. Of course, power demand has been pretty high in South Asia, and any [additional] supply — particularly from the U.S. — that would have gone to those markets is just getting sucked up by Europe," he added. As coal prices also rise, "Pakistan and particularly India have switched to oil derivatives for power generation."

KENYA SWITCHES TO COOKING WITH CHARCOAL: As the price of liquefied petroleum gas, also known as cooking gas, rises, families in Kenya are turning to charcoal instead — with all the attendant health problems and deforestation concerns. The stuff is made from charring wood, and the illegal logging trade to cash in on the demand is on the rise.

TECH CORNER

The Guardian and Washington Post dropped a bomb on Uber over the weekend, releasing parts of an ICIJ investigation based on more than 124,000 leaked documents over a five-year period from executives at the ride-sharing giant. The documents reveal questionable practices pushed by billionaire founder Travis Kalanick, aggressive lobbying of then-Vice President Joe Biden, a dismissive attitude toward then-Hamburg mayor Olaf Scholz and then-Economy Minister Emmanuel Macron's secret attempts to help Uber win support in France.

Read Kalanick's response to the allegations, via a spokesperson, here.

YOU KNEW THIS WAS COMING: Elon Musk dropped memes on Twitter making fun of the brewing lawsuits over his decision to rescind his acquisition of the social network he recently promised to buy and retool.

MASTICATED: Meanwhile, in other rough news for billionaires, Jeff Bezos is going to have to find a new way to set sail, after officials in Rotterdam refused to dismantle a bridge to let his new megayacht reach open waters.

INTERVIEW — CLAIRE JUNGMAN

Claire Jungman is chief of staff at the United Against Nuclear Iran nonprofit in New York. She's been tracking the shipping tankers that have clandestinely moved Tehran's U.S.-sanctioned oil, gas and petrochemicals to willing buyers around the globe since 2018, when then-U.S. President Donald Trump pulled out of the JCPOA deal. She's also watched those ships switch to carrying Russian oil in the wake of recent Western sanctions. According to UANI, Chinese purchases of Iranian oil alone could exceed $25 billion this year — thanks to a so-called "ghost armada" of some 200 rickety vessels that ferry the high seas largely unsanctioned by American authorities.

What are the techniques Iran uses to move its oil? 

"There are a number of deceptive practices, with spoofing being the number one we're seeing . We used to see vessels 'go dark' a lot more frequently — that's when they turn off their AIS transponder [the unique satellite tracking signal all ships emit] — but then people got smart and realized ships that went dark were up to no good. So now we see spoofing, where they are actually manipulating their transponder to appear as if they are anchored in one location, but in reality they are loading at ports in Iran or engaging in ship-to-ship transfer. The vessel basically spoofs its transponder when it loads the Iranian oil, then conducts a ship-to-ship transfer out at sea to offload that oil with vessels that have, say, Malaysian oil on them. Or it may not even be Malaysian oil, but they're in Malaysian waters so they're able to rebrand the oil as Malaysian blend. It's a very small amount — out of 700,000 barrels a tanker can hold, it will take on maybe 40,000 barrels, but it's enough that they can basically re-produce documents to say, that's a Malaysian blend."

How does payment happen? 

"It's a little bit of a sketchy process. My understanding is that Iran does not sell its oil unless it receives money up-front, basically. China is the number one importer, followed by Syria. Since 2019, we've seen discount prices range from $12 [per barrel lower than market rates] to a $2 or $3 discount. Right now, Russian oil is being discounted more than Iranian oil, so we're seeing a little bit of a decline in Iran's oil exports to China, with Russian oil exports to China going up."

Why are these ships now switching from carrying Iranian oil to Russian? 

Since the Russia-Ukraine crisis chartering rates have gone up in the Black Sea and Baltic Sea, because it's more dangerous for vessels to be operating in that area — I believe chartering rates are around $30,000 a day. That's why we're starting to see vessels we call the Ghost Armada which typically transport Iranian oil, now shift to carrying Russian crude, as owners and operators receive more money to use those ships. The number of ships that have made the switch from moving Iranian oil to Russian so far is up to 13 they range in sizes but all together can carry approximately 12 million barrels of oil. If we add in ships normally carrying Venezuelan oil that have switched to Russian, it's up to 25 vessels.

Why aren't existing sanctions being enforced on these ships? 

We saw a little bit of early enforcement from the Biden administration, but I think they were so focused on trying to get a new deal with Iran that they were reluctant to enforce sanctions on its oil exports because it would disrupt negotiations. Over the last few months we've seen more enforcement, which is promising, but there is more work to be done. Specifically, to bring Iranian oil exports back down the 200-plus vessels currently transporting Iranian oil should be sanctioned.

Industry as a whole has also been slow to follow the deceptive practices, and as a result they're sort of enabling this type of activity — and if they can't crack down on it with Iran, I don't know how they're going to crack down on it with Russia.

Insurance companies are the most reactive and responsive, they don't want to be responsible for insuring cargo that is sanctioned, but most of them aren't tracking at the level we're tracking, so some [ships] go under the radar. But when the insurance ban on Iranian oil took place, we saw most of these vessels using not the international Protection & Indemnity insurance companies, but establishing their own P&I clubs. Some ports won't accept the cargo if it's not insured by an international P&I club — but most of the countries that want to buy the sanctioned oil, China for example … won't care what P&I club it has.

Classification societies, their job is just to make sure a vessel is up to safety standards and fit to sail the seas, they're not technically responsible for looking at the cargo — but there have been some cases where they will take action and declass vessels. Panama is the largest ship registry in the world — I think out of the 200 vessels we track carrying Iranian oil about 37 percent are flagged by Panama. They should very much have the resources and capabilities to track at the levels we track and be responsible … but they seem to be turning a blind eye.

What more can be done?

There needs to be continuous monitoring and a process where they hit the vessel with sanctions right away. But that's not what we see — it's a very slow moving process, and you can sanction the entire [Russian] Sovcomflot fleet, but you know, they're going to turn to using other vessels. In addition, sanctions on the purchasers of the oil would help. I'm sure we would see a decline in Iranian oil exports to China if the U.S. started sanctioning Chinese importers.

 

Congressional Vision for Tech Across America – July 21 Event : How can innovation play a role in America's global economic leadership? On July 21, Rep, Gerry Connolly (D-VA), Rep. Tom Emmer (R-MN), Rep. Trey Hollingsworth (R-IN), Rep. Ro Khanna (D-CA), Sen. Jacky Rosen (D-NV), Rep. Mikie Sherrill (D-NJ) are sharing Congress' vision for the future of policy and technology surrounding workforce and education at MeriTalk's MerITocracy 2022: American Innovation Forum. The forum will feature Hill and White House leadership and industry visionaries as they dig into the need for tangible outcomes and practical operational plans. Save your seat here.

 
 
BRAIN FOOD

Inside the race, and rightward swerve, of the Tory candidates to replace Boris Johnson.

The Economist: A new web of Arab railways could transform the Middle East

Thanks to editor Ben Pauker and producer Hannah Farrow. 

SUBSCRIBE to the POLITICO newsletter family: D.C. Playbook | Brussels Playbook | London Playbook | Paris Playbook| EU Confidential | D.C. Influence | EU Influence | London Influence | Digital Bridge | China Direct | Berlin Bulletin | Living Cities

 

Follow us on Twitter

Ryan Heath @PoliticoRyan

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to edwardlorilla1986.paxforex@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to unsubscribe.

No comments:

Post a Comment

3 Days Only–Get $150 Off

Save on purchases of $1,000 or more.    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏    ͏  ...