Wednesday, December 2, 2020

Grading Erin O’Toole’s first 100 days — Who wants an election? — Two years of a deep freeze in Canada-China relations

Go inside the corridors of power in Ottawa politics.
Dec 02, 2020 View in browser
 
Corridors header

By Maura Forrest

Welcome to POLITICO's newest community: Corridors, which will be delivered to your inbox every Wednesday. Interested in more granular POLITICO Canada coverage? Get in touch to learn more about POLITICO Pro.

Did someone forward you this newsletter? Subscribe here.

Erin O'Toole has been the third leader of the Conservative Party of Canada for 100 days, and has been working to rebrand his party. But this week, he was still introducing himself to Canadians.

Welcome to Corridors. I'm your host, Maura Forrest. In today's edition: Erin O'Toole's first 100 days, what the fiscal update says about an election, and the two-year anniversary of the deep freeze in Canada-China relations. Get in touch: mforrest@politico.com

DRIVING THE WEEK

THE FIRST HUNDRED DAYS — It's not been easy for the new leader of the official opposition to make a name for himself in the thick of a global pandemic. Standard Conservative talking points about reining in government spending don't have quite the same cachet just now, and O'Toole has had to find new ammunition with which to attack Prime Minister Justin Trudeau — lately, he's seized on the Liberals' vaccine rollout.

He's also still trying to tell people who he is. During his speech Monday in response to Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland's fall economic statement, O'Toole talked about his upbringing in Bowmanville, Ont., his first job as a dishwasher and his 12 years with the Canadian Armed Forces.

Still, being something of a blank slate has allowed O'Toole to craft an image of himself as an average guy sticking up for other average guys. "Conservatives are here to fight for those who build things in Canada, those who get their hands dirty and take pride in doing a job well before they come home for the night," he said Monday.

In the last 100 days: O'Toole has railed against elites and the decline of private-sector unions, demanded the Liberals get tough on China, played political chicken on a confidence vote, and paid a more or less successful visit to Quebec must-watch talk show Tout le monde en parle. He has observers talking about how he's reorienting his party toward the working class — some with more skepticism than others.

Dodging pitfalls: He's so far avoided much damage on social conservative issues, despite the fact that he's allowing free votes on two controversial bills — on conversion therapy and assisted dying — that are currently making their way through Parliament. He's made clear he is personally pro-choice and pro-LGBTQ rights.

Oh, and he also caught Covid-19 soon after he won the leadership, which was sub-optimal, but certainly memorable.

What's next: With a possible election on the horizon, O'Toole is trying hard to appeal to constituencies in the GTA and Quebec the Conservatives will need if they're to have a shot at winning. But where he's been less clear is on his party's own offerings — for the Covid-19 recovery, for instance, or for tackling climate change.

For more: Check out Althia Raj's deep dive on Erin O'Toole first 100 days for the Huffington Post.

HALLWAY CONVERSATION

Corridors asked Conservative strategists to comment on O'Toole's performance during his first 100 days, including what's been most notable and where he's fallen short.

Andrew Brander, senior consultant at Crestview Strategy: It's more than likely in 100 days from now, we're going to be staring down the barrel of an election. So I really view this as the halfway mark for O'Toole to be in a position to convince enough Canadians he is ready to be prime minister.

Erin has made significant progress in unifying the party and focusing on the regions [where] the party must see gains in order to be viable. He's the first leader the Conservatives have had from Ontario … and he's got a team explicitly devoted to Quebec strategy.

While he came up short, under O'Toole's leadership, the margin in [the York Centre byelection] shrunk from almost a 6,000 vote loss for the Tories in 2019 to just 700 just a year later. If he can replicate this during a general election, the path is wide open for O'Toole to form a government.

Alise Mills, senior counsel at Sussex Strategy Group: What stood out immediately when Erin O'Toole was elected and what has made him a fierce adversary for the Trudeau government has [been his] extensive comprehension of Canada's most important files and the critical challenges, both nationally and regionally, that face Canadians.

Looking to Covid-19, he hasn't often spoken to the social gaps that the pandemic has revealed or worsened. Mr. O'Toole gets full marks for holding the Trudeau government accountable on economic recovery and the procurement of vaccines, but he needs to demonstrate his understanding of the complexities of our social recovery.

Jamie Ellerton, principal at Conaptus PR: Thoughtful and agile in the House of Commons and already building a fresh team of candidates for the next election, his leadership has brought Conservatives a renewed optimism.

While getting COVID has probably been most notable, his focus on a better approach to China policy and challenging the government to be better on its pandemic response reveals a growing foundation to make a compelling case to Canadians to be the next government.

YOU TELL US

Corridors is a new weekly newsletter for MPs, lobbyists, executives, activists and any readers who are interested in what's going on around Parliament Hill. Every Wednesday we will look at the people pulling the levers of power in Ottawa and the questions that are influencing decisions on Parliament Hill and in the provinces. Join the conversation! You can email us at mforrest@politico.com, ablatchford@politico.com, lgardner@politico.com and sallan@politico.com.

THIS WEEK ON THE HILL

REALITY CHECK — The fiscal update landed Monday, at long last, which means it's time for a fresh round of everybody's favorite: election speculation! The Liberals will introduce a bill to implement parts of the economic statement as early as today, which will lead to a confidence vote that could bring down the government. There are a few things to remember here, though. One is that it's December, Covid-19 cases are spiking across the country, and the Liberals are still leading in the polls. The opposition was gun-shy in October, the last time an election seemed like a possibility, and if they didn't go for it then, it's unclear why they would now.

Another is that the entirety of the fall economic statement will not be up for a vote. The Liberals only need to pass legislation to enact certain measures — for example, their C$2.4-billion top-up to the Canada Child Benefit, which O'Toole took credit for on Monday. The opposition parties haven't yet said whether they'll vote against the bill, but they've generally supported emergency financial aid during the pandemic.

Also: Trudeau said Tuesday he's "reasonably confident" no party wants an election right now, and added that all parties should be able to find things they support in the bill. A Liberal source tells Corridors the bill should pass after Parliament resumes in late January, and there's "no drama expected."

If not now, when? The bigger question is how soon the Liberals might find a more opportune moment to head to the polls. Reuters on Tuesday reported that insiders say an election is likely coming in 2021, when Freeland's promised C$70 billion to C$100 billion in stimulus spending will start to roll out and Covid-19 vaccines will — theoretically — become widely available. Writing for the Globe and Mail, Campbell Clark argues that Freeland's stimulus plan will form the backbone of the Liberals' next election bid. In the Toronto Star, Heather Scoffield says the economic statement does "double-duty as an election platform." Ditto from Don Martin over at CTV News.

Heads up: The National Post reported Tuesday evening that Paul Rochon, deputy minister of Finance Canada, sent out a resignation letter to staff just one day after the fiscal update was released.

VACCINE POLITICS — If you'd accidentally happened upon O'Toole's speech in the House of Commons on Monday, you'd have been hard-pressed to guess he was responding to a fall economic statement. O'Toole took a few requisite jabs at the size of the deficit, but spent most of his time attacking the Liberals' pandemic response, especially the vaccine rollout, claiming Canada is "near the back of the line." The Conservatives clearly see more opportunity in the Liberals' shaky messaging on vaccine distribution than in government accounting. As John Ibbitson recently wrote for the Globe and Mail, "there'll be hell to pay" if Canadians have to wait months longer for immunizations than our neighbors to the south.

The Liberals have been working hard to build confidence in their vaccine deployment plans since Trudeau admitted last week that Canada may have to wait longer than some other countries. And they've been given a boost in recent days by Moderna officials saying Canada will actually be among the first to receive doses once its vaccine is approved. Trudeau is suggesting most Canadians could be immunized by September, while a new poll finds voters may not be as worried about timing as the Conservatives might have hoped.

On Tuesday, Procurement Minister Anita Anand pushed back against what she called "misinformation," insisting vaccines will arrive in the first quarter of 2021, pending approval from Health Canada. The regulator is currently evaluating four vaccine candidates from Moderna, Pfizer, AstraZeneca and, as of this week, Johnson & Johnson. "I am negotiating with our vaccine suppliers every day for earlier delivery dates," Anand said during a press conference.

Hot off the press: The U.K. on Wednesday approved the Pfizer vaccine for emergency use, becoming the first Western nation to approve a Covid-19 vaccine, and may begin inoculating its citizens next week.

Related: Remember near the end of Contagion when they decide to use a birthday-based lottery to roll out their vaccine? That may turn out to be the least plausible part of that movie, aside from the part where the CDC, you know, functions. Canada's first vaccines are expected to go to high-priority groups like the elderly, health-care workers and Indigenous communities. On Tuesday, chief public health officer Dr. Theresa Tam said the easiest way to roll out doses after that is by age group, since older people are more likely to get seriously ill.

In the meantime: Several cabinet ministers will have to explain to the House of Commons industry committee what happened to Canada's plan to manufacture vaccines domestically, thanks to a Conservative motion passed on Tuesday. The Tories have also served notice of an opposition day motion calling on the government to provide details of its vaccine plans in the House of Commons by Dec. 16.

UNHAPPY ANNIVERSARY — This week marks two years since the arrest of Huawei senior executive Meng Wanzhou, which triggered a rapid deterioration of Canada-China relations. The sore spots are numerous, from China's detention of two Canadians following Meng's arrest to Canada's criticism of Beijing's national security law for Hong Kong. And then, of course, there's Canada's looming decision about whether to allow Huawei technology in this country's 5G networks.

As POLITICO reports this morning, the incoming Biden administration may deepen the U.S. government's resolve to get western democracies like Canada to ban the Chinese telecom giant's equipment. Canada has yet to announce its decision on Huawei, but a senior government official tells POLITICO's Andy Blatchford it's coming "soon."

China policy: Conservative MP Garnett Genuis, co-chair of Parliament's special committee on Canada-China relations, says the Liberal government needs a China policy. "There's, I think, a big lack of clarity now in terms of what they actually want, what their plans are and that's creating a lot of problems," Genuis told Andy in an interview Tuesday. "I think the government has been very, very naive for a long time about what is going on. And the government has tried to sound a little bit tougher lately, but we haven't actually seen any new policy."

Meanwhile, the Globe and Mail reported Tuesday that Canada-China trade has actually increased during the pandemic compared to last year, despite the frosty relations.

PLEASE, SIR, WE WANT SOME MORE — Trudeau is slated to meet with the provincial and territorial premiers Dec. 10 to discuss federal funding for health care, but is remaining non-committal about whether he'll meet their demand for increased health transfers. The premiers say Ottawa is currently covering only about 22 percent of total health care costs, and are demanding an increase to 35 percent. But Monday's fiscal update was silent on the matter, which Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet seized on as a major point of contention. Trudeau said Tuesday he's "look[ing] forward" to next week's discussion.

EXPECTED TODAY — CBC News is reporting the Liberals will admit today they won't meet their target to lift all drinking-water advisories in First Nations by March 2021, but are promising another C$1.5 billion to get the job done. Meanwhile, the government is planning to introduce its bill to implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples as early as Thursday.

ON THE NOTICE PAPER

The Tracey J. Hubley Scholarship for Community Leadership will recognize a student with a strong appreciation for the power of public policy to make positive community change.

The Tracey J. Hubley Scholarship for Community Leadership will recognize a student with a strong appreciation for the power of public policy to make positive community change. | Courtesy Summa Strategies

Movers and shakers: Brock Harrison, former communications director to Andrew Scheer, just took over as executive director of communications and planning in Alberta Premier Jason Kenney's office. He replaces Katy Merrifield. … Congrats to the new and/or upgraded members of the Order of Canada, including Monique Bégin, Joan Fraser, Peggy Nash, Allan Rock and a trio of Bills (Blaikie, Graham and Fox).

Spotted: Canada's ambassador to the U.N. Bob Rae in Central Park. Conservative MP Todd Doherty learning that he's about to be a grandfather. Meet Ren Kathleen!

Birthdays: HBD one day early to Ottawa MP Anita Vandenbeld, who will be 49 … Senator Claude Carignan (56) and MP William Amos (46) celebrate Friday, as does Ottawa pundit and media trainer Barry McLoughlin … Senator Stephen Greene will be 71 on Tuesday — a date when MPs Yvan Baker and Shannon Stubbs will also blow out some candles.

Anniversaries: The House recently recognized the "deans of the Conservative Caucus" — MP Cheryl Gallant of Renfrew-Nipissing-Pembroke and MP Scott Reid of Lanark-Frontenac-Kingston — for their 20th anniversaries in the Commons.

Honors: The life and legacy of Tracey Hubley is being celebrated with a scholarship in her name at the University of Prince Edward Island. The Summa Strategies president died in March. "It's not easy to capture the spirit of someone so special in one scholarship, but this one involves P.E.I., community building and good causes — three things that Tracey was passionate about," says Summa VP Jim Armour. He tells us that Summa has endowed the Tracey J. Hubley Scholarship for Community Leadership but hopes that with donations from friends, colleagues and clients, they will be able to increase the annual amount of the award.

Got a tip, event, birthday, anniversary, new job, or any other suggestion for Corridors? Let me know: mforrest@politico.com

The Reading Room

Canada started talking about child care in 1970. Writing in the Walrus, Anne Casselman considers the question we've been asking ever since: What's taking so long?

Writing with former PBO Kevin Page in Policy, undergrads Jeffrey Bugg and Shannon Smith respond to the government's "whatever it takes" mantra with a quote from Jurassic Park.

Margaret MacMillan joins Maclean's Paul Wells in conversation tonight. They'll discuss history, obviously, but also talk about this year of hellfire.

Feature writer Joe O'Connor profiles Jerry Dias — "the '$5-billion' blue-collar man" — in the Financial Post.

And as U.S. policymakers grapple with China's dominance in producing the materials needed for clean energy and cutting-edge technology, the case of cobalt serves as a warning. POLITICO's Luiza Savage and Ryan Heath explain why on the latest episode of Global Translations.

Pro Zone

Bipartisan group of senators pushes USTR to drop foreign trade zone proposal.
Canada's reality check: Deficit approaches C$400B with stimulus spending to come.
What comes next? Liberals outline "down payment" on C$100 stimulus plan.
Canada pledges unilateral tax on digital giants in 2022 if global talks fail.
ECB's Lagarde welcomes U.S. return to multilateralism under Biden.
Behind Trump's final push to limit immigration.

TRIVIA QUESTION

Congratulations to Michael Read, national executive coordinator of the Federation of Medical Women of Canada, who was first to guess that the governing party sits to the left of the speaker in Newfoundland's legislature because back in the 19th century, the heaters in the old Colonial Building were located on the left side, so it was the warmest part of the House of Assembly.

Here's this week's question:

Name the fruit that now shares its name with one of the government's new pandemic relief programs.

Email mforrest@politico.com with your answers — or with trivia suggestions!

With thanks to Editor Sue Allan, Luiza Ch. Savage and Andy Blatchford

 

Follow us on Twitter

Maura Forrest @mauraforrest

 

Follow us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Instagram Listen on Apple Podcast
 

To change your alert settings, please log in at https://www.politico.com/_login?base=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.politico.com/settings

This email was sent to edwardlorilla1986.paxforex@blogger.com by: POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

Please click here and follow the steps to unsubscribe.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Have You Ever…

No, seriously - I am curious. ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏  ͏ ...